Apple Engineers Reveal the Fragility of AI 'Reasoning'

Source: AIPT

Published on: 17 Oct 2024

Tags: artificial intelligence, large language models, Apple


In today’s rapidly evolving tech landscape, large language models (LLMs) have become a hot topic in the field of artificial intelligence. These models are not only capable of generating coherent text but can also tackle various complex problems. However, a recent study by Apple engineers has shed light on the fragility of these models’ “reasoning” capabilities. This research has garnered significant attention, and let’s dive into this fascinating topic.

Apple research
large language model

Firstly, what is “reasoning”? Simply put, reasoning is the process of deriving new conclusions based on known information. In human cognition, reasoning is a fundamental mental process that helps us solve problems and make decisions. For AI, however, this capability is far from mature. The Apple research team tested multiple large language models and found that they exhibit significant instability when handling certain types of problems.

For instance, when faced with logical reasoning puzzles, these models often produce incorrect conclusions. A classic example is the “wolf, goat, and cabbage” river-crossing problem. This puzzle requires a person to safely transport a wolf, a goat, and a cabbage across a river without leaving the wolf alone with the goat or the goat alone with the cabbage. Despite its simplicity, many large language models fail repeatedly when attempting to solve this problem. This indicates that while these models excel at generating natural language, they struggle with tasks that require multi-step logical reasoning.

AI reasoning
Apple research

Moreover, the Apple study revealed that these models falter when dealing with ambiguous information. For example, when the input information is unclear or open to multiple interpretations, the models often fail to provide reasonable answers. This limitation can have serious consequences in practical applications, particularly in fields such as medical diagnosis and legal consultation. Therefore, while large language models perform well in certain tasks, we must maintain a clear understanding of their limitations.

That said, this research is not intended to completely dismiss the value of large language models. On the contrary, it serves as a reminder to use these technologies more cautiously. As the Apple engineers point out, these models still hold tremendous potential for specific tasks. For instance, in areas like text generation, translation, and customer support, large language models have already demonstrated remarkable achievements. Thus, we should continue to explore ways to improve these models and enhance their performance in a broader range of applications.

large language model
AI reasoning

In conclusion, the Apple study provides a crucial perspective on the shortcomings of large language models in terms of “reasoning.” This insight not only helps us better understand how these models work but also points to directions for future research. Hopefully, in the near future, we will see more intelligent and reliable AI systems.



Name*

Email*

Comment